Atrium Roofing
(210) 807-6767
$1,500 off STORMLOCK™ · ends 11/11 →
Standing seam metal roof installed on a two-story San Antonio home under blue Texas sky.
Materials hub

Every roofing material, honestly compared.

Not every material is right for every home. Here’s how to choose based on your climate, budget, and how long you plan to stay.

Get My Free Roof Inspection(210) 807-6767Book Online
We call back within minutes, any hour. No obligation.
Jose Puente, Civil Engineer and owner of Atrium Roofing.
Content reviewed and approved by Jose Puente, Civil Engineer and owner of Atrium Roofing since 2016.
Meet Jose

The full comparison table

MaterialLifespanWind ratingHailCostIdeal for
Architectural shingle15–20 yrs110–130 mphUsually unrated$Most homes — the price-to-lifespan sweet spot.
Designer shingle20–25 yrs130 mphClass 3–4$$High-visibility homes where curb appeal matters.
Class 4 impact-resistant18–24 yrs130 mphClass 4$$Hail-prone areas — often earns an insurance discount.
Standing seam metal40–50 yrs150+ mphExcellent$$$Modern homes, hill country, and long-term owners.
Concrete tile40–50 yrs150 mphVery good$$$$Mediterranean and Spanish-style architecture.
Clay tile50+ yrs150 mphVery good$$$$$Historic and luxury homes with sufficient structure.
Aerial view of a brick home finished with a copper-toned laminated shingle roof.
Designer laminated shingle in an aged copper color on a San Antonio home.
Aerial view of a house with a black laminated shingle roof and multiple gables.
The same shingle line in black on a New Braunfels roof, for color comparison.
Get Roofing Material Recommendations
Manufacturers

Who we install — and why

Owens Corning
SureNail technology, TruDefinition color palette. We are Platinum Preferred, Owens Corning's top contractor tier.
GAF
North America’s largest manufacturer. Timberline HDZ and premium Grand Sequoia designer line.
Atlas
Scotchgard-protected shingles with excellent algae resistance — great for shaded homes.
Malarkey
Rubberized polymer-modified shingles with strong impact and cold-weather performance.

How to actually choose

Staying under 10 years: Standard architectural shingle. Don’t over-invest in a roof the next owner will benefit from. Here is how it compares with the older flat style: architectural vs 3-tab shingles.

Staying 10–20 years: Class 4 impact-resistant shingle. Class 4 impact-resistant shingles can qualify for a premium discount in Texas. The amount is set by your insurance carrier, so ask your agent what yours would be.

Staying 20+ years or forever home: Standing seam metal.

Historic or luxury home: Tile — but only after a structural review confirms your framing can carry the weight.

Material FAQs

For most homes, an architectural shingle with SBS-modified asphalt (like Owens Corning Duration Flex or GAF Grand Sequoia AS) hits the sweet spot: a 18–24 years service life, Class 4 impact rating, and a reasonable price. If you plan to stay 20+ years, metal is worth the upgrade.

For lifespan, yes: 40–50 years versus 15–20 years for architectural shingles. But they cost 2–3x upfront, and improperly detailed metal roofs leak just as badly as shingles. The installer matters more than the material.

Impact resistance rating from UL 2218 testing. Class 3 survives 1.75" steel ball impacts; Class 4 survives 2" impacts. Class 4 impact-resistant shingles can qualify for a premium discount in Texas. The amount is set by your insurance carrier, so ask your agent what yours would be.

Yes. Concrete tile weighs 9–12 lbs per sq ft; clay 6–10. Many stick-built homes weren’t engineered for tile and need structural reinforcement before installation.
Not sure which material fits your home?

We’ll spec three options with real numbers — no upsell.

Get My Free Roof Inspection(210) 807-6767